Uncertain: Finish or abandon?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a3536/a35362ef19ffbb6db853e10a73c10424750153d7" alt="Ghosts - Noel Hynd"
I don't know whether or not to finish this novel. It's good, yet something's...missing. The editing could be better, as well, the prose tightened.
At 37% on the Kindle. Should I continue? Just the fact that I am questioning tells me I should not. But it has 4 stars on Booklikes, and 3.94 over at Goodreads. Still...